Analyzing Madonna's 'Cherish': A Model Essay

This page offers a comprehensive example essay analyzing Madonna's 1989 hit song 'Cherish.' It serves as a valuable resource for students and professionals looking to understand how to approach popular music as a subject of academic study. The essay demonstrates critical analysis by examining lyrical content, musical composition, thematic development, and the impact of its accompanying music video. Below, you'll find the full essay, followed by a breakdown of its structure, key analytical components, and revision considerations.

Essay Analysis: Structure and Thesis

The essay on 'Cherish' is structured to guide the reader logically through a multifaceted analysis. It begins with an introduction that establishes the song's significance and presents a clear thesis statement: that 'Cherish' is a sophisticated piece of art blending pop sensibilities with nuanced exploration of romantic commitment, supported by lyrical sincerity, innovative production, and visual storytelling. The body paragraphs then systematically unpack these elements. The organization moves from lyrical themes to musical arrangement, then to Madonna's career context, and finally to the music video's impact. This progression allows for a comprehensive understanding, building from the song's core components to its broader cultural significance. The conclusion effectively synthesizes these points, reiterating the thesis and offering a final thought on the song's lasting value.

Thesis Statement: The Core Argument

The central argument, or thesis, is articulated in the introductory paragraph: 'While superficially appearing as a straightforward declaration of love, a closer examination reveals a sophisticated interplay of lyrical sincerity, innovative production, and visual storytelling that solidifies its place not only as a commercial success but also as a significant artistic statement.' This statement is strong because it makes a specific claim ('sophisticated interplay,' 'significant artistic statement') that is debatable and requires evidence to support. It also acknowledges the initial, simpler interpretation ('straightforward declaration of love') before presenting the more complex analytical viewpoint. This sets up the essay to explore the layers of meaning within the song and its presentation.

Evidence and Support: Lyrical and Musical Detail

Effective analysis relies on concrete evidence. In this essay, evidence is drawn directly from the song's lyrics, such as "I can't take it / I can't stand it... When you're not around" and "'Cause I'm gonna cherish you / Through whatever and all." These quotes are not merely presented but are interpreted to support the claim about the song's focus on devotion and commitment. Similarly, musical elements are described with specific detail: the "opening synth arpeggios," the "synthesized string section," and Madonna's "breathly, intimate tone" versus her "strength and conviction" in the chorus. This level of detail grounds the analysis in the actual sonic and lyrical components of the song, demonstrating how these elements contribute to the overall meaning and impact. The discussion of the music video also uses descriptive language to highlight its visual impact and thematic resonance.

Organization and Flow: Paragraph Cohesion

Each paragraph in the sample essay focuses on a distinct aspect of the analysis, contributing to a coherent overall structure. Transitions between paragraphs are generally smooth, often signaled by thematic links. For instance, the discussion of lyrical themes naturally leads into the musical arrangement, as the music enhances the emotional weight of the words. The shift to the music video is introduced by noting its iconic status and how it "directly complements the song's lyrical themes." This logical flow ensures that the reader can follow the argument without getting lost. The use of topic sentences at the beginning of paragraphs helps to orient the reader to the main point of each section.

Tone and Style: Academic Voice

The essay maintains a formal, academic tone suitable for scholarly analysis. It avoids slang, overly casual language, and subjective opinions presented as fact. Instead, it uses precise vocabulary (e.g., "nuanced exploration," "sophisticated interplay," "ethereal vision," "stylized") and objective language to describe and interpret the subject matter. While appreciative of the song's artistry, the tone remains analytical rather than purely laudatory. Sentence structure is varied, incorporating both complex sentences for detailed explanations and shorter sentences for emphasis, contributing to a natural reading rhythm. Contractions are generally avoided to maintain formality.

Revision Opportunities: Enhancing the Analysis

  • Deeper Contextualization: While the essay mentions the Like a Prayer album context, further exploration of specific musical trends of the late 1980s or critical reception of the song/album could strengthen the analysis.
  • Comparative Analysis: Briefly comparing 'Cherish' to other Madonna songs exploring similar themes (e.g., 'Crazy for You') or to contemporary pop ballads could highlight its unique qualities.
  • Production Specifics: While mentioning instrumentation, a more detailed breakdown of specific production techniques (e.g., use of reverb, specific synth sounds, vocal layering) could offer deeper insight.
  • Music Video Deconstruction: The video analysis is good, but a more detailed deconstruction of specific shots, editing techniques, or symbolic elements could be beneficial.
  • Audience Reception: Discussing how the song was received by audiences and critics at the time, and how its reception might have evolved, could add another layer.
Example: Analyzing a Lyrical Phrase

Consider the phrase: "I can't take it / I can't stand it / When you're not around." In the essay, this is used to illustrate dependence. A more detailed analysis might explore the implications of this dependence. Is it healthy? Is it possessive? How does the upbeat musical arrangement contrast with the potential negative connotation of such strong dependence, creating a subtle tension? For instance, one could write: 'The stark declaration, "I can't take it / I can't stand it / When you're not around," while seemingly a simple expression of longing, carries a weight that is subtly undercut by the song's buoyant tempo and bright synth melodies. This juxtaposition creates an interesting tension: is this devotion, or a veiled form of co-dependency presented in an accessible pop package? The song's success suggests audiences embraced the former, perhaps overlooking the potential complexities inherent in such intense reliance, a common characteristic of romantic narratives in popular music.'

Checklist for Analyzing Popular Music

  • Identify the Core Thesis: What is the main argument about the song's meaning or significance?
  • Examine Lyrical Content: What themes are explored? How are they expressed (metaphor, direct statement, etc.)?
  • Analyze Musical Elements: Consider melody, harmony, rhythm, instrumentation, production techniques, and vocal delivery.
  • Connect Music and Lyrics: How do the musical elements enhance or contrast with the lyrical message?
  • Consider the Artist's Context: How does the song fit within the artist's broader career, discography, and public image?
  • Evaluate Visual Components: Analyze music videos, album art, or live performances for thematic or symbolic relevance.
  • Research Historical/Cultural Context: What was happening musically, socially, or culturally when the song was released?
  • Assess Reception: How was the song received by critics and audiences? Has its interpretation changed over time?
  • Formulate a Clear Argument: Ensure your analysis supports a specific, arguable thesis statement.